I want to tell you about someone who was imprisoned here in Burlington. Fabricio was born in El Salvador, where he was violently attacked by gangs. When he reported these crimes to the Salvadoran police, they would do nothing to protect him or hold his attackers accountable. In 2014, Fabricio took the brave step to flee this violence and come to the U.S. where he has been living and working in Massachusetts. Upon entering this country Fabricio applied for asylum, following a lawful process, and his case remains pending. After 12 years of waiting, the government finally scheduled his asylum hearing for January 7th 2026.
Fabricio appeared for his asylum hearing at the U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) office in the JFK Federal Building in Boston. But when Fabricio showed up, ICE agents appeared, handcuffed him, put him in an unmarked SUV, drove him here to Burlington, and locked him in a cell. The agents presented no warrant and provided no reason his abduction. The ICE Boston social media account posted a photo of Fabricio handcuffed inside an SUV. The post stated that he is “a criminal alien and suspected gang member from El Salvador” and that he had been “charged with an OUI in the United States”. Eventually he was transferred to the Wyatt Detention Facility in Rhode Island.
In the United States it’s supposed to be illegal to deprive a person of liberty without charging them with a crime or allowing for due process, so Fabricio hired an attorney who filed a habeas petition challenging the legality of his arrest and detention. After reviewing Fabricio’s case, a federal judge ruled that ICE’s arrest and detention of Fabricio was illegal. On January 16th, after 9 days in prison, the judge ordered ICE to release Fabricio and schedule a bond hearing.
Fabricio was released, and on January 22nd he appeared virtually for a bond hearing at Chelmsford Immigration Court. According to the Immigration and Nationality Act, the government can only deny bond and detain an immigrant living in the U.S. if the government proves “by clear and convincing evidence” that the person poses a danger to the community. At Fabricio’s virtual bond hearing, the DHS attorney did not present a single piece of evidence to justify denying bond. Instead, the only thing the DHS attorney submitted to the court was a piece of paper known as an I-213 form. This I-213 form is filled out by ICE agents, where they write down their reasons for abducting someone. ICE agents can write anything they want on these forms.
At the virtual bond hearing, here’s what the DHS attorney said to the immigration judge: “[DHS] is arguing [that Fabricio] holds a danger and a flight risk… [The] evidence, um, that we have filed is a I-213. Within that I-213, um, there is information regarding [Fabricio]… being charged in 2011 in El Salvador with illicit associations and robbery.” After stating this allegation, which was written by ICE agents on a I-213 form, the DHS attorney then actually said to the judge: “[DHS] admits that this attorney is not in receipt of that evidence, [and DHS] did not file it with the court.” So all DHS provided to the Court was a form written by ICE agents with no evidence.
In response, Fabricio’s attorney said to the immigration judge: “All we have is an accusation… on the I-213, I see a mention of charges… [but] as we submitted in our evidence, we conducted our own search in El Salvador and were not able to find any of these charges... I certainly see no evidence of any convictions… so I would say that the, you know, DHS position on the gang membership appears right now to be a purely unsupported accusation… [Fabricio] has been in the U.S. since 2014… he has a clean CORI check,” showing no criminal history.
So how did the immigration judge rule after DHS presented not a single piece of evidence? The immigration judge declared: “[Fabricio] is a danger to the community by clear and convincing evidence, and so the court is denying bond.” Now, we have a right to wonder why an immigration judge ruled that Fabricio is a gang member without a single piece of evidence to support this allegation.
The answer is that immigration judges are not actual judges. They are employees of the Department of Justice, which is part of the Executive Branch, not the Judicial Branch. They wear robes and pose as judges, but their job is to assist the government in detaining and deporting as many people as possible. Laws, facts, evidence, our Constitution, these are all inconveniences to be ignored in immigration court.
In the past, there were some immigration judges who had standards, who worked to uphold the Constitution and the laws specified in the Immigration and Nationality Act, but these judges are long gone. They’ve all been fired by the Trump administration. Since 2025, more than 100 immigration judges have been fired, and the purge continues. Just this past Friday, the Department of Justice fired 3 immigration judges in Massachusetts, including the judge who ruled against deporting Rümeysa Öztürk.
Our government is now working to replace these fired judges with loyal servants. The Department of Justice launched a recruitment campaign back in December, featuring social media ads with these words: “We’re looking for patriotic legal professionals to serve as Deportation Judges. Your work will have generational consequences.” Our government doesn’t even call these employees immigration judges, they call them “Deportation Judges”. Like the Department of War, this renaming makes their true purpose crystal clear.

The reality is that our immigration courts are run by Deportation Judges who give legal cover so ICE can continue terrorizing, detaining, torturing, and deporting anyone. For individuals like Fabricio who fled violence and applied for asylum, these Deportation Judges don’t care about him. They don’t care that he followed a lawful process. In the past year, Deportation Judges rejected more than 90 percent of asylum claims.
If these so-called judges evaluated cases based on facts, evidence, the Constitution, and the Immigration and Nationality Act, our government’s concentration camps would be empty, our neighbors would be home with their families, and our communities would be much safer.
So for Fabricio, after an immigration judge denied him bond and declared him a danger to society, he found himself in a very strange situation. On one hand a federal judge had ruled that his arrest and detention was illegal, and so he was released, but then a couple weeks later a so-called immigration judge ruled that he should be detained. Fabricio’s attorney filed a motion in federal court to prevent ICE from re-detaining Fabricio based on the absurd denial of bond ruling by the Deportation Judge.
Unfortunately, federal judges and a federal Court can only intercede in an immigration case when an immigrant is currently in custody. Fabricio had been released prior to his virtual bond hearing, and so he was not in detention at that time. The federal judge wrote, “Should ICE take him back into custody or place any other restrictions on his liberty, Mr. España is free to pursue appropriate relief in this Court.” Meanwhile Fabricio kept going to work, somehow managing to function in daily life, knowing that ICE could abduct him again at any moment.
Well, 50 days later on March 13th, Fabricio walked out of his home in Woburn to go to work, and ICE agents abducted him. The agents brought him back here to Burlington, and behind the blacked-out fence in the back of this facility they took him out of an unmarked SUV in shackles, took a photo of him, and posted it on social media. The post stated that Fabricio is “a criminal illegal alien and suspected gang member from El Salvador.” Once again, no evidence was provided, and of course ICE neglected to mention that Fabricio is a lawful asylum seeker who fled gang violence.
After imprisoning Fabricio here in Burlington for a second time, ICE transported him to Plymouth County Correctional. Fabricio’s attorney once again filed a habeas petition for his release, and once again a federal judge ruled that Fabricio’s Constitutional right to due process had been violated, and again ordered his immediate release. In the span of three months, Fabricio had been abducted, imprisoned, and released, then abducted, imprisoned, and released, all because of unfounded accusations that ICE agents wrote on a form.
They say the pen is mightier than the sword, but ICE has pens and swords, they have forms and guns, they have social media posts and unmarked vans, they have bogus administrative warrants and windowless cells, and they have hundreds of attorneys and Deportation Judges who are eager to violate our Constitution. ICE must be abolished.
Immigration judges must be moved from the Executive Branch to the Judiciary, so that the Constitution and evidence, not racism and xenophobia, determine the outcome of every court hearing in America. But for now and for the foreseeable future, immigration attorneys must fight for their clients within this rotten, illogical, immoral, and illegal immigration court system.
I was speaking with an immigration attorney who told me, “I feel like I’m pushing a boulder uphill that’s just gonna crush me any minute.” These immigration attorneys are heroes, because they don’t give up, they still believe in the rule of law, and they still believe in justice, despite the hypocrisy and lies thrown at them from DHS attorneys and Deportation Judges. We must support these attorneys.
Call to action: Support legal services for immigrants
At our weekly Bearing Witness @ ICE protests in Burlington, we have a “truth table” — a table covered in a patchwork of vignettes describing the experiences of immigrants who have been detained in Burlington, as well as information about conditions inside the facility. The table also features QR codes that link to trusted resources and organizations that help immigrants secure legal representation, pay bond, and more. These organizations remain in need of financial support.
Call to action: Bear witness at immigration court
The foundation of Bearing Witness is the belief that wherever government officials are carrying out cruelty to immigrants, wherever they are violating the Constitution and human rights, there should always be compassionate people present to bear witness with their own eyes, to see what is happening, to show support for those being victimized, and then to share what is seen and heard to educate others. If you or someone you know is looking for another way to bear witness, you can attend immigration court hearings. Immigration court hearings are open to the public. You can show up, enter the courtroom, bear witness, and then share what you’ve witnessed. If you’re in Massachusetts, you can bear witness at Chelmsford Immigration Court where Fabricio faced injustice, and at Boston Immigration Court.
In 2025, the American Bar Association launched an Immigration Court Observation and Awareness Project. This project offers online training for volunteers with no legal experience to observe and capture data during immigration court hearings. The data collected by these volunteers helps attorneys better understand the practices and trends in immigration courtrooms, so they can be better prepared when they fight for their clients. Even if you do not plan on bearing witness yourself, please consider sharing this information with others who might be interested. Thank you.
Sources
España v. Nessinger et al. (February 23, 2026) (Court order)
España v. Nessinger et al. (March 25, 2026) (Court order)
How Trump Purged Immigration Judges to Speed Up Deportations (NY Times)
Franklin is helping write the next chapter of America. You can too! (Department of Justice)
Descriptions of forms and supporting documents (Department of Justice)
Council Challenges USCIS’s Refusal to Release I-213s and Other Immigration Records (American Immigration Council)
Immigration judges who ruled in Öztürk, Mahdawi cases fired (WGBH News)
Tufts international graduate student taken into ICE custody (WGBH News)
ICE Boston X post, January 9, 2026 (ICE)
ICE Boston X post, April 5, 2026 (ICE)
Office of the Chief Immigration Judge (Department of Justice)
Bearing Witness @ Immigration Court (Information sheet)
Eyes on Justice: Observing Immigration Courts in Action (American Bar Association)
Volunteer Registration - Immigration Court Observation & Awareness Project (American Bar Association)



Excellent work as always. The immigration courts need a complete overhaul, as do many things in the USA.
Intentional injustice by design.